Martha Brigham (foreground) and Grace Ng as Amy and Esther in Dry Land. Photo: Ben Krantz Studio

Shotgun Players is no stranger to plays that push people’s boundaries. In fact, the Berkeley theater specializes in “projects that other companies might deem too expensive, too unwieldy, or just plain impossible.” 

Shotgun’s current production, Dry Land, is definitely on the “impossible” end, and it’s pushing so many buttons that it’s “had an impact on our box office,” according to an email sent to theater patrons last week. And yet, true to its mission, Shotgun has actually decided to extend this play, in the hopes that a few more people might take the chance to hear this particular story. 

The play focuses on a complicated relationship between two teenage girls on a high school swim team, one of whom is facing an unwanted pregnancy. It is gritty and raw and real: the playwright, Ruby Rae Spiegel, was a 21-year-old Yale student when the play first premiered in New York. The production has been very well received by younger audiences, such as Berkeley High School students, but many older audiences — who are the theater’s core supporters  — are finding the play too disturbing and challenging.

Near the play’s conclusion, an actress playing a pregnant teen has a painful miscarriage — a DIY abortion — right on stage, in what feels like real time. The scene is long, it is graphic and gruesome, and viscerally painful to watch. There is a lot of thick blood and other bodily fluids: everything is revealed, nothing is left to the imagination. Most nights at least one person walks out to the lobby during the performance feeling dizzy, and some theatergoers have even fainted (once even stopping the production).

“You may hate it or you may love it, but you are going to have to go home and be with it,” said Martha Brigham, who plays the lead character Amy. What she calls the “big scene” is so intense that the playwright has built in a six-minute interval right afterwards, when a janitor cleans the mess on the stage very slowly and thoroughly, to allow people time to process what they have just witnessed. 

Because of audiences’ intense reactions, even those who love the play are not talking about it or recommending it to their friends, said Shotgun managing director Liz Lisle. And while this silence has taken “a toll on ticket sales,” the theater has decided to extend the play anyway.

“We wanted to give more people a chance to see this show, even if it’s only 40 people a night,” said Shotgun’s founding artistic director Patrick Dooley. “We feel this is such an important event to share with our audience. Theater is a place where we can talk about things people are most ashamed of, most afraid of. The playwright really wanted to take this topic out of the shadows.” 

Dooley said the play impacted him deeply from the first time he read it. “I grew up in rural West Virginia, and people there are moms and dads at 19 and 20,” he said. His own mother was a high school valedictorian, and then got pregnant with him during her senior year of college.

“There is something so primal about this particular experience,” he said. “As a teenager, part of your body is an adult — you can give birth — but you are still a child. You are negotiating what it means to have intimate relationships, and it’s all coming at you so quickly.” Dooley said that the Berkeley High School swim team got very involved in the play. “The adults were more scandalized than the young people were,” he said.

Esther (Grace Ng) sits on Amy (Martha Brigham) in an attempt to force a miscarriage. Photo: Ben Krantz Studio

Don’t ask, don’t tell

“People are having vastly different opinions about this show: it is one of the most polarizing productions we have ever done,” Lisle said. “A lot of that has to do with where people reside on the spectrum of being comfortable with what the human body does, and how this is displayed realistically on the stage. Some people find that very exciting and powerful, and others see it as disgusting, something that doesn’t have a place in the theater.”

“We are looking for stories that have not traditionally been told about women,” Lisle added. “We want to stage narratives that are clearly prevalent in our culture, but don’t get a lot of exposure.” At one performance, the only standing ovation was from a teenage boy. During the talk back, he said that he was grateful because the play gave him access to an experience he could never have witnessed otherwise.

“The play asks audiences to see things that they don’t want to see,” said Ariel Craft, who directed Dry Land. “When it comes to the struggles of young women, people often have a ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ mentality. They feel we shouldn’t be burdened by seeing these things. But these are real experiences that people have every day. For young people — high school and college kids — none of this is too surprising.”

In general, older women seem more upset by this play than older men, Craft said. However, Brigham noted that she sees more men leaving the theater during the abortion scene than women. “Men have never had to deal with anything remotely close to this,” she said. “It makes them very uncomfortable to watch it.”

Amy (Martha Brigham) and Esther (Grace Ng) navigating through difficult choices. Photo: Ben Krantz Studio
Amy (Martha Brigham) and Esther (Grace Ng) navigating through difficult choices. Photo: Ben Krantz Studio

A story that needs to be told

The play takes place in the locker room of a Florida high school, and much of the action focuses on the relationship between Amy and Esther, a new girl at school. In Florida, teens need parental consent for an abortion, and Amy does not feel she can get that consent from her mother. So she spends most of the play trying to induce a miscarriage, with the help of Esther and hare-brained ideas she gleans from the internet.

“There is something so beautiful and human about their relationship,” Dooley said. “That experience is transformative: as you watch it happen, awful as it is, you can see what it’s like to be supported and to support someone else.”

“This is a story that’s not told a lot, and it needs to be told,” Brigham said. “I have heard so many stories from people of different ages. Mostly it’s women who come up to me and hug me, and want to tell me about experiences they had with abortion. I had a woman last night who told me she had an illegal abortion in London, and this is exactly what it was like.”

Brigham has also had high school students tell her about their experiences with abortion, and their friends’ experiences. “They stay for the talk back, and they have discussions with older people who don’t quite understand that this is still happening, even in Berkeley,” she said.

Brigham said she is able to perform that scene because the cast has grown very close over the weeks of rehearsal and performance, and they created a sense of safety for her. “I am not going to lie: I was definitely nervous and scared at the beginning,” she said. “But we had an environment that was all women [at the early part of rehearsals], and it was  a step-by-step process. You start doing the scene, and over time you reveal more and more. I’ve had a lot of time to process this. The audience just saw it one night, so they are still processing.”

She said that the abortion scene is performed like “a choreographed dance” between herself and fellow actress Grace Ng, who plays Esther. “Grace is there by my side, holding my hand the whole time, shifting her body constantly to accommodate me,” she said. “We’ve become very close through this process.”

The play does not take a position about abortion: it just shows, in a no-holds-barred-way, what an illegal abortion looks like. “It’s just telling you that these things happen,” Brigham said, “and we should be having conversations about it.”

Berkeleyside readers can use the discount code— BERKDL —to get $10 off the ticket price of remaining shows. Dry Land has been extended to June 23. A talk back follows every performance.

Freelancer Daphne White began her reporting career in Atlanta and then worked as a journalist in Washington, DC, for more than a decade. She covered Congress, education and teachers’ unions, and then...